Every time I see you fall
Scattered pictures on the floor
And you wonder,is this worth it
Standing miles behind the truth
Is there ever any proof?
And you wonder,is this worth it
Don't you know life can be beautiful somewhere,
We all get lost sometimes,don't be scared …
Who knows what life is really all about?
I am trying but
Who knows what love is really all about?
I am dying but
Who knows,who knows?
Who knows what life is really all about,
Cause I really don't.
Quietly caught in a trap
Full of hate you can't look past
And you wonder is this worth it
Used to always being refused
Feel there's nothing left to lose
And you wonder is this worth it
There is a part in you that you cannot let down
I know the feeling well,don't let it keep you bound
Who knows what life is really all about?
I am trying but
Who knows what love is really all about?
I am dying but
Who knows,who knows?
Who knows what life is really all about,
Cause I really don't.
What if life came to a halt?
And everything you had was broken,or taken
Would you think things a little differently
Would small things cause no misery
Cause our lives are whatever we make them …
Who knows what life is really all about?
I am trying but
Who knows what love is really all about?
I am dying but
Who knows,who knows?
Who knows,who knows?
Who knows what life is really all about,
Cause I really don't know …
Who Knows - 喬毓明
更多更詳盡歌詞在 ※ Mojim.org 魔鏡歌詞網
https://mojim.org/song/喬毓明-Who-Knows-80574
移調 原調
C#A#mD#C#F#FmC#D#D#mF#mC#A#mC#D#F#FmC#A#mC#CD#D#mF#mC#FmC#FmFD#FmA#mFmC#FmC#G#C#D#A#mC#DmDF#mC#D#D#mF#C#FmC#CD#DmDF#mC#C#mC#F#F#mAF#mC#FmA#mC#mD#A#mD#DADC#A#mC#D#A#mC#F#C#A#mC#D#C#mAF#mC#A#mD#D#mA#mD#mF#FmC#FmC#A#mD#
和弦由 AI 自動分析音訊產生（僅供參考）。
AI 從音訊辨識的主旋律（以 C# 調為 1，數字上下點為高低八度）。為自動估計、個別音可能有誤，僅供哼唱抓調參考，非正式樂譜。彈唱請看「和弦」分頁。
跟這首歌對話
AI 依歌詞回答（免費，僅供參考）
曲解析
《Who Knows》調性為 C# 大調、速度約每分鐘 81 拍、整體情緒溫暖。主要和弦為 C#、D#、A#m、Fm。（以上為 AI 音訊分析，僅供參考）
歌詞解析
一句話主旨
面對生命與愛情的無常，人們在困惑中尋求答案卻始終無法確知。
主題
探討生命意義與愛情本質的不可測性，以及人在困境中的掙扎與自我勵勉。
情緒
迷茫、掙扎與尋求答案的焦慮，夾雜著對希望的微弱期待。
意象與手法
「散落的相片」象徵破碎的記憶或關係；「充滿仇恨的陷阱」隱喻情緒困境；反覆出現的「Who knows」強調對命運的無力感，而「我們的生命是自己創造的」則作為矛盾修辭，於絕望中隱藏自主性。
重點句解讀
1. 「Who knows what life is really all about?」
重複的疑問句凸顯對生命本質的困惑，暗示個人經驗的有限性與世界複雜性的對立。
2. 「I am dying but...」
「垂死」象徵精神或情感的崩潰，卻未明確說明原因，強化處於絕望邊緣的抽象痛苦。
3. 「Our lives are whatever we make them」
矛盾性的肯定句在連續質疑中出現，暗示自我救贖的可能，卻未給予明確解答。
適合情境
面對人生抉擇、情感困局或存在主義思考時，作為情緒共鳴與自我反思的陪伴。
魔鏡站長解析
站長私房短評：打動人的地方、適合什麼時刻聽（產生後永久保存）。
歌曲冷知識
AI 依歌詞整理 3-4 點有趣觀察（產生後永久保存）。